Practical Ethics: A Field Guide for Resource Managers

Edition: 1

Copyright: 2023

Choose Your Format

Choose Your Platform | Help Me Choose

Ebook Package

$71.66

ISBN 9798765749760

Details eBook w/KHPContent Access 180 days

This coursebook will illustrate how, and how often, a forester is in a position that requires an ethical response compelled by circumstances that will be beyond your control (think unstable markets, need of additional revenue when faced with unexpected equipment repairs, and delays caused by inclement weather). In instances like these, you’ll be asked to consider the line between right-doing and wrong-doing alongside deeper complications like what to do when what seems wrong, is also legal. If the bind you’re in involves a choice between grades and types of good, are you better off asking which move is more correct than another? How you answer these questions will have real consequences because behavior, character, and reputation go hand in hand. In the business of forestry, all these things, from how we act to how we are seen by others, matter a great deal.

Professional Acknowledgements

Preface

A First Letter to Foresters

Introduction

A Tried-and-True Approach

The Good and the Useful

Intended Audience

The Purpose of This Book

Grounding the Methods

Some Notes on Thinking and Why You Should Do It

Chapter 1: Application of the Common Good

An Introduction to the Method

Outline of Key Questions

Logging Subcontractors

From the Field: Kyle L. Burdick

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Talk of the Trade

Community Impacts of Logging

Logging Full Time or on a Contract Basis

Timber Trespass on Forest Preserve Land

From the Field: Timothy Burpoe CF

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Downstream Runoff

From the Field: Alex Barrett

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 2: Application of Practical Wisdom

An Introduction to the Method

Outline of Key Questions

Procurement and Forest Certification

From the Field: Michael Federice CF

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Talk of the Trade

Good-Faith Procurement

Private Land Procurement

From the Field: Tony Doster F

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Conservation Easement Violation

From the Field: Christi Barber

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 3: Application of Pre-Modern Ethics

An Introduction to the Method

Outline of Key Questions

Bribery and Conflict of Interest

From the Field: Aaron Gilland, CFE

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Personal and Professional Boundaries

From the Field: Jake Metzler CF

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Crossing the Line

From the Field: Jake Denkenberger

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 4: Application of Rights

An Introduction to the Method

Outline of Key Questions

Rewilding State Land

From the Field: Sean Reynolds

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Talk of the Trade

Tax Abatement and Cutting Against the Plan

Tax Abatement, a Response

Tax Abatement on Private Land

From the Field: Mike Federice CF

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 5: Application of the Greatest Good

An Introduction to the Method

Outline of Key Questions

A Clear-Cut Case

From the Field: Kian Sullivan CF

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

An Hourly Rate or by Percentage

From the Field: Lynn Levine

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Inventory Audit

From the Field: Nan Pond, PhD and Nathan Rutenbeck

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 6: Application of Rational Ethics

An Introduction to the Method

Outline of Key Questions

Conservation Easement Violation

From the Field: Corrie Magee CF

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Dual Ownership

From the Field: Robert Ripp

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Talk of the Trade

Managing the Family Farm

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 7: Application of Relational Approach

An Introduction to the Method

Outline of Key Questions

Hardwood Shelterwood Harvest

From the Field: Trevor Keough

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Adverse Possession

From the Field: Kenneth Wade Morgan

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Hemlock Infestation

From the Field: Calvin Norman

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 8: Integrating Approaches

Carbon Sequestration in the Pacific Northwest

From the Field: Kenneth L. Rosenbaum

Timberland Appraisal

From the Field: Samuel J. Radcliffe

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 9: Rhetorical Means of Persuasion

Introduction to the Method: A Case Concerning Recreation on State Land

An Historical Example: Forestry and the Source

Pinchot and Leopold: Wise Use

Forestland Conversion

From the Field: Collin Miller CF

Field Notes

Afterward

A Last Letter to Foresters

Author Bio

MARIANNE PATINELLI DUBAY

This coursebook will illustrate how, and how often, a forester is in a position that requires an ethical response compelled by circumstances that will be beyond your control (think unstable markets, need of additional revenue when faced with unexpected equipment repairs, and delays caused by inclement weather). In instances like these, you’ll be asked to consider the line between right-doing and wrong-doing alongside deeper complications like what to do when what seems wrong, is also legal. If the bind you’re in involves a choice between grades and types of good, are you better off asking which move is more correct than another? How you answer these questions will have real consequences because behavior, character, and reputation go hand in hand. In the business of forestry, all these things, from how we act to how we are seen by others, matter a great deal.

Professional Acknowledgements

Preface

A First Letter to Foresters

Introduction

A Tried-and-True Approach

The Good and the Useful

Intended Audience

The Purpose of This Book

Grounding the Methods

Some Notes on Thinking and Why You Should Do It

Chapter 1: Application of the Common Good

An Introduction to the Method

Outline of Key Questions

Logging Subcontractors

From the Field: Kyle L. Burdick

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Talk of the Trade

Community Impacts of Logging

Logging Full Time or on a Contract Basis

Timber Trespass on Forest Preserve Land

From the Field: Timothy Burpoe CF

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Downstream Runoff

From the Field: Alex Barrett

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 2: Application of Practical Wisdom

An Introduction to the Method

Outline of Key Questions

Procurement and Forest Certification

From the Field: Michael Federice CF

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Talk of the Trade

Good-Faith Procurement

Private Land Procurement

From the Field: Tony Doster F

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Conservation Easement Violation

From the Field: Christi Barber

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 3: Application of Pre-Modern Ethics

An Introduction to the Method

Outline of Key Questions

Bribery and Conflict of Interest

From the Field: Aaron Gilland, CFE

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Personal and Professional Boundaries

From the Field: Jake Metzler CF

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Crossing the Line

From the Field: Jake Denkenberger

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 4: Application of Rights

An Introduction to the Method

Outline of Key Questions

Rewilding State Land

From the Field: Sean Reynolds

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Talk of the Trade

Tax Abatement and Cutting Against the Plan

Tax Abatement, a Response

Tax Abatement on Private Land

From the Field: Mike Federice CF

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 5: Application of the Greatest Good

An Introduction to the Method

Outline of Key Questions

A Clear-Cut Case

From the Field: Kian Sullivan CF

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

An Hourly Rate or by Percentage

From the Field: Lynn Levine

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Inventory Audit

From the Field: Nan Pond, PhD and Nathan Rutenbeck

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 6: Application of Rational Ethics

An Introduction to the Method

Outline of Key Questions

Conservation Easement Violation

From the Field: Corrie Magee CF

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Dual Ownership

From the Field: Robert Ripp

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Talk of the Trade

Managing the Family Farm

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 7: Application of Relational Approach

An Introduction to the Method

Outline of Key Questions

Hardwood Shelterwood Harvest

From the Field: Trevor Keough

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Adverse Possession

From the Field: Kenneth Wade Morgan

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Hemlock Infestation

From the Field: Calvin Norman

Field Notes

Spot the Problem

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 8: Integrating Approaches

Carbon Sequestration in the Pacific Northwest

From the Field: Kenneth L. Rosenbaum

Timberland Appraisal

From the Field: Samuel J. Radcliffe

Primary Sources for Further Reading

Chapter 9: Rhetorical Means of Persuasion

Introduction to the Method: A Case Concerning Recreation on State Land

An Historical Example: Forestry and the Source

Pinchot and Leopold: Wise Use

Forestland Conversion

From the Field: Collin Miller CF

Field Notes

Afterward

A Last Letter to Foresters

Author Bio

MARIANNE PATINELLI DUBAY